The Impact of Politicized Media & Opinion-Based Information on Ocean Conservation
Published on 1/15/25
Written by Jessica Colla
As media and politics increasingly shape the narrative around climate change and conservation, misinformation and polarization threaten progress. This article unpacks the impact of politicized media on public opinion and marine policy while offering practical ways to stay informed, bridge divides, and take meaningful action to protect our planet.
This blog may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, Kaimana Conservation may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. Your support helps us continue our mission to promote ocean conservation and education. Thank you!
As Inauguration Day approaches on January 20th, political messaging and the influence of media are once again taking center stage in shaping public opinion and policy. Regardless of who holds political power—whether individuals, political groups, or entire administrations—one truth remains: we, the people, must continue to support grassroots movements and remain steadfast in our commitment to environmental conservation!
This is especially vital for ocean conservation, a global cause that transcends political divides. In a time when environmental issues like climate change and sustainable energy are increasingly politicized, it’s easy to lose hope. However, even in the darkest environmental times, there is still light—a hope that can come from individual actions, shared education, and the collective interest in making a difference.
1. The Politicization of Environmental Issues:
Environmental topics like climate change, ocean pollution, and sustainable energy have become deeply politicized in recent decades. This shift began when scientific data started to challenge industries that rely on fossil fuels, unsustainable agriculture, and deforestation—activities that contribute to environmental degradation. Political parties, often aligned with these industries, began to frame environmental conservation efforts as part of their opposition’s agenda, branding them as either a threat to economic growth or an overblown concern. As a result, climate change and energy policy became battlegrounds where partisan ideologies clashed rather than a shared global challenge requiring collective action.
Ocean conservation is no exception. As rising sea levels, acidification, and marine biodiversity loss threaten coastal communities, the scientific community and conservationists have pushed for urgent action. Yet, the conversation around sustainable ocean practices has been shaped by political divides and opinion-based information outlets. The question should not be about whether ocean protection should be a priority; it’s about how we, as a society, can unify to protect our oceans for future generations.
2. Information Siloing: How Regionality & Algorithms Control Our Knowledge:
One of the risks of living in a digitally-connected world is the phenomenon of information silo-ing, where we only consume content that aligns with our existing beliefs and biases. Algorithms that power online platforms like social media and search engines are designed to show us content that fits our demographic profile—age, location, interests, and past consumption habits. This creates a filter bubble, limiting our exposure to diverse viewpoints and information.
For example, someone living in a region with a strong political opposition to climate change action might see only news stories that reinforce skepticism toward environmental science, while someone with similar interests in environmentalism might be surrounded by content that confirms their beliefs in sustainability and green technologies. This divide is exacerbated by regionality, as people in coastal areas might have a different perspective on ocean conservation than those living inland or far from the ocean. As a result, our understanding of environmental issues becomes narrower and more disconnected from the scientific consensus.
For ocean conservation, this is dangerous. The most pressing issues facing our oceans—overfishing, plastic pollution, coral bleaching, and ocean acidification—require collective global action. But when the information people receive is filtered through political or regional biases, it becomes harder to form a united front. People may feel that environmental conservation is someone else's problem, or that it’s a divisive issue rather than a shared responsibility.
3. The Risks to Environmental & Conservation Initiatives:
The risks of information silo-ing for ocean conservation and environmental initiatives are considerable. Misinformation and skewed content can lead to public apathy, misinformed decisions, and a lack of urgency in addressing pressing environmental issues. Without access to balanced and fact-based content, the public may fail to grasp the scope of the ocean’s plight or the actions necessary to mitigate further damage.
Moreover, the rise of “fake news” and disinformation campaigns related to climate change and sustainability poses an additional challenge. It’s easy for climate skeptics and opponents of environmental protection to spread doubt and mistrust of the science and solutions proposed by experts. This undermines efforts to pass policies that protect our oceans, supports renewable energy, and creates sustainable practices for all industries.
Media Information & Political Bias Chart by Ad Fontes Media (https://app.adfontesmedia.com/chart/interactive)
4. How to Overcome Information Silo-ing & Seek Unbiased Sources:
As individuals and advocates, it’s crucial to seek out non-biased and reliable sources of information. Trusted organizations like PBS, National Geographic, and The Ocean Conservancy offer research-driven content and educational materials about ocean conservation. By following expert organizations and scientists, people can access accurate information and understand the broader, interconnected environmental challenges we face.
Additionally, participating in local community efforts or becoming involved in grassroots organizations can help ensure that we stay informed and take action. Grassroots movements allow us to bridge divides, work across political lines, and push for systemic changes in the way we interact with our environment.
5. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):
How can I tell if the environmental information I’m reading is biased or politically-driven?
Answer: It's important to check the source of the information. Trustworthy outlets, like PBS, National Geographic, and reputable scientific organizations, base their content on peer-reviewed research. Be cautious of articles that lack cited sources, sensationalist headlines, or content that consistently aligns with a particular political stance. Seeking multiple viewpoints and cross-referencing information can help ensure you’re getting a more balanced perspective.
What are some practical steps I can take to help support ocean conservation, even if I don’t agree with the political climate around climate change?
Answer: Regardless of political views, everyone can contribute to ocean conservation. Simple actions like reducing plastic use, participating in beach cleanups, supporting sustainable fisheries, or advocating for renewable energy in your local community can make a difference. Joining grassroots organizations and spreading awareness through personal conversations are also great ways to contribute.
Why is ocean conservation such a political issue? Why can’t everyone agree that we need to protect our oceans?
Answer: The politicization of ocean conservation often comes from the economic interests tied to industries that harm the oceans, like fossil fuels, overfishing, and unsustainable tourism. When certain industries are threatened by environmental regulations, they lobby against those regulations, leading to political polarization. However, it's important to remember that ocean conservation benefits everyone, regardless of political beliefs, and requires collective action.
How does information silo-ing affect the way we view ocean conservation efforts?
Answer: Information silo-ing occurs when people only consume information that aligns with their pre-existing beliefs. This means individuals might be exposed to misleading or incomplete views on ocean conservation, particularly in areas where political agendas clash with scientific facts. This siloing can prevent people from understanding the true urgency of ocean protection or hinder bipartisan efforts for environmental change.
What are some reliable, non-biased resources for staying informed about climate change and ocean conservation?
Answer: Trusted resources include PBS, The Ocean Conservancy, National Geographic, and other scientific journals and organizations. These sources are grounded in research and provide fact-based, scientifically accurate information. Engaging with these platforms and diversifying your sources of information can help break through the bias of siloed content.
If climate change and ocean conservation are such important issues, why does the media often downplay or misrepresent them?
Answer: Media outlets often cater to their target audience, and sensationalizing or simplifying complex issues like climate change can generate higher viewership or engagement. Additionally, some media outlets may be influenced by political affiliations or financial backing from industries that oppose strict environmental regulations. This results in a distorted portrayal of the issues, making it harder for people to get the full picture of the environmental crises we face. Lastly, media outlets may downplay complex topics like climate change due to the feeling of overwhelm and hopelessness often associated with them, which can lead to decreased viewership. By avoiding these topics or simplifying their coverage, outlets attempt to retain audience attention, even at the expense of providing comprehensive and accurate information.
How can I stay hopeful about ocean conservation when political leaders don’t seem to prioritize the environment?
Answer: It's understandable to feel disheartened by the political landscape, but hope still lies in grassroots movements, individual actions, and community efforts. While governments and political leaders play a role, real change often comes from the ground up—through education, advocacy, and the collective effort of people who care about the planet. By getting involved in local initiatives, supporting sustainable practices, and continuing to learn and share knowledge, you can be part of the solution.
Is it possible to make a meaningful impact on ocean conservation if my local policies don't prioritize environmental protection?
Answer: Absolutely! Even if local policies don’t prioritize the environment, individuals and communities can still make a big impact. Supporting sustainable businesses, reducing waste, protecting local ecosystems, and advocating for better environmental policies on the local and state level are all ways to make a meaningful difference. Every action, no matter how small, contributes to the larger effort.
What can I do if I feel overwhelmed by the environmental challenges we face?
Answer: It’s normal to feel overwhelmed when confronted with urgent global issues like ocean conservation, but remember that every small action counts. Focus on things you can control—like reducing your carbon footprint, supporting environmental education, and encouraging others to take action. Connecting with like-minded individuals through advocacy groups or conservation organizations can also provide support and inspiration.
How can I bridge the divide between different political views when discussing ocean conservation?
Answer: The key is to focus on shared values and the universal benefits of ocean conservation. Emphasize that protecting oceans isn’t a partisan issue—it’s a matter of global survival, economic stability (especially for coastal communities), and environmental health. By presenting ocean conservation as a non-divisive issue and encouraging open, respectful dialogue, you can help others see the importance of the cause without getting bogged down by political divisions.
Final Thoughts:
As we enter another political era where environmental protection may take a back seat to other agendas, it’s important to acknowledge the difficult road ahead. The new administration may not prioritize environmental education or funding, and this could have profound consequences for our oceans and ecosystems.
However, all hope is not lost. By continuing to educate ourselves, support unbiased sources, and take individual action—whether through lifestyle changes, reducing our carbon footprint, or sharing knowledge with others—we can foster a culture of ocean conservation that transcends politics. Together, we can keep the light of hope alive, empowering each other to make a real difference.
Hope is not something we should place solely in the hands of politicians. It lies in our collective actions and the belief that, no matter the political climate, the ocean will continue to need us. Let’s work together for a brighter, more sustainable future.
SHOP JESSICA’S FAVORITE
OCEAN-LOVER ESSENTIALS
From sustainable household items to quirky sealife accessories, these tried-and-true products are sure to make you smile!
Marine invasive species are reshaping ocean ecosystems—learn how lionfish, green crabs, zebra mussels, and more disrupt habitats, threaten biodiversity, and impact fisheries. Discover the biggest offenders, their effects, and how we can take action to protect marine life.